The fragile boundary between ‘education’ and ‘educationalisation’: some personal reflections on the often exaggerated educational aspirations of museums ; La frágil frontera entre «educación» y «educacionalización»: algunas reflexiones personales sobre las aspiraciones, a menudo exageradas, de los museos

Although the origins of school museums and museums of children and childhood do not coincide directly, they nevertheless have moved into the same direction during the past decades. Especially because chil­dren are an important part of the visitors, a lot is invested by these mu­seums in educational support and activities. Pedagogical arguments form the backbone of their mission statements. A bit against the tide of this trend, I want to pay attention here to the often exaggerated educa­tional aspirations. To my mind the boundary between “education” and “educationalisation” is a fragile one and... Mehr ...

Verfasser: Depaepe, Marc
Dokumenttyp: Artikel
Erscheinungsdatum: 2021
Verlag/Hrsg.: UNED
Schlagwörter: Historiografía educativa / Historia de la infancia / Representación en museos / Bélgica / Letonia / Educational historiography / Childhood history / Representation in museums / Latvia / Belgium
Sprache: Englisch
Permalink: https://search.fid-benelux.de/Record/base-28943955
Datenquelle: BASE; Originalkatalog
Powered By: BASE
Link(s) : https://revistas.uned.es/index.php/HMe/article/view/32106

Although the origins of school museums and museums of children and childhood do not coincide directly, they nevertheless have moved into the same direction during the past decades. Especially because chil­dren are an important part of the visitors, a lot is invested by these mu­seums in educational support and activities. Pedagogical arguments form the backbone of their mission statements. A bit against the tide of this trend, I want to pay attention here to the often exaggerated educa­tional aspirations. To my mind the boundary between “education” and “educationalisation” is a fragile one and can be easily exceeded if the cultural-historical context of the museum content is ignored too much. Educating young people does not necessarily mean taking them by the hand and leading them through well-developed work packages, but is related to the more complex process of Bildung – the formation of a per­son, which usually starts, in view of attitudes and behaviour, by reflec­tion about self-identity as well as societal values and norms. In my opin­ion the encounter with well-chosen artefacts of former pedagogical mentalities and realities in museums of education, children and child­hood, can be helpful in this respect. Therefore, my plea for more cul­ture-historical contemplation and less educational strategy in represent­ing education, children and childhood is not to be understood as phasing efforts in this sector. On the contrary, the shift of emphasis from the neoliberal focus on efficiency, management, and social relevance (also in terms of a possible instrumentalization) of educational history towards more scientific, cultural-historical underpinning will need continuous support. ; Aunque los orígenes de los museos escolares y de los museos de la in­fancia y la niñez no coinciden directamente, sin embargo, se han movido en la misma dirección durante las últimas décadas. Especialmente porque los niños son una parte importante de los visitantes, estos museos invierten mucho en apoyo y actividades educativas. Los ...