Centripetalism in Consociational Democracy:The Multiple Proportional Vote and the Belgian Case

Belgium illustrates that using consociational institutions in divided societies may ensure a peaceful political environment, but it fails in reducing its centrifugal tendencies. As communitarian issues threaten to paralyse the political debate, preserving the efficiency of the state will require adding centripetal incentives to the consociational framework. However, the solution usually proposed for this purpose - the creation of a federal constituency - would be insufficient. Instead, this paper advocates the adoption of a new electoral system: the Multiple Proportional Vote (MPV). MPV is abl... Mehr ...

Verfasser: De Briey, Laurent
de Briey, Aurian
Dokumenttyp: Artikel
Erscheinungsdatum: 2024
Reihe/Periodikum: De Briey , L & de Briey , A 2024 , ' Centripetalism in Consociational Democracy : The Multiple Proportional Vote and the Belgian Case ' , Swiss Political Science Review , vol. 30 , no. 2 , pp. 108-130 . https://doi.org/10.1111/spsr.12603
Schlagwörter: Federalism / Electoral Systems / Consociational democracy / Centripetalism / Belgium
Sprache: Englisch
Permalink: https://search.fid-benelux.de/Record/base-28880564
Datenquelle: BASE; Originalkatalog
Powered By: BASE
Link(s) : https://researchportal.unamur.be/en/publications/3bd86b82-fabb-4c6e-84c7-6ece880af675

Belgium illustrates that using consociational institutions in divided societies may ensure a peaceful political environment, but it fails in reducing its centrifugal tendencies. As communitarian issues threaten to paralyse the political debate, preserving the efficiency of the state will require adding centripetal incentives to the consociational framework. However, the solution usually proposed for this purpose - the creation of a federal constituency - would be insufficient. Instead, this paper advocates the adoption of a new electoral system: the Multiple Proportional Vote (MPV). MPV is able to maintain the consociational goal of including the different communities in the parliament, as well as to strengthen the centripetal trends towards moderation. Indeed, electors of every group are allowed to cast their preferences for candidates of the other communities. As such, MPV suggests that consociationalism and its main theoretical alternative, centripetalism, are far from mutually exclusive. ; Belgium illustrates that using consociational institutions in divided societies may ensure a peaceful political environment, but it fails in reducing its centrifugal tendencies. As communitarian issues threaten to paralyse the political debate, preserving the efficiency of the state will require adding centripetal incentives to the consociational framework. However, the solution usually proposed for this purpose –the creation of a federal constituency– would be insufficient and would raise legitimacy problems analogous to those occurred in Bosnia, the Swiss Canton of Berne or Cyprus. Instead, this paper advocates the adoption of a new electoral system: the Multiple Proportional Vote (MPV). MPV can maintain the consociational goal of including the different communities in the parliament, as well as to strengthen the centripetal trends towards moderation. Indeed, electors of every group are allowed to cast their preferences for candidates of the other communities. As such, MPV suggests that consociationalism and its main ...