The Secret of the Court in the Netherlands

The procedural organization of the legal system in the Netherlands is quite different from the North American model. The Dutch legal system forbids the publication of dissenting opinions. There is even a veil of ignorance about unanimity, created by what is "secret of the court": justice is handed out in black and white terms, regardless of the judges' motivations. This might create an image of unity and unanimity, and thus promote the legitimacy of jurisprudence, however, this secret of the court also prevents the effects of therapeutic jurisprudence, since those who have "won," but even more... Mehr ...

Verfasser: van Manen, Niels F.
Dokumenttyp: Text
Erscheinungsdatum: 2000
Verlag/Hrsg.: Seattle University School of Law Digital Commons
Schlagwörter: therapeutic jurisprudence / appellate court / court of appeals / netherlands / international law / north american legal system / dutch legal system / minorities / dutch law / dissent opinions / Jurisprudence / Law and Psychology / Law and Society / Legislation / Litigation / Other Law
Sprache: unknown
Permalink: https://search.fid-benelux.de/Record/base-27594213
Datenquelle: BASE; Originalkatalog
Powered By: BASE
Link(s) : https://digitalcommons.law.seattleu.edu/sulr/vol24/iss2/22

The procedural organization of the legal system in the Netherlands is quite different from the North American model. The Dutch legal system forbids the publication of dissenting opinions. There is even a veil of ignorance about unanimity, created by what is "secret of the court": justice is handed out in black and white terms, regardless of the judges' motivations. This might create an image of unity and unanimity, and thus promote the legitimacy of jurisprudence, however, this secret of the court also prevents the effects of therapeutic jurisprudence, since those who have "won," but even more so those who have "lost," would benefit from insight into why the court has ruled and whether or not there was disagreement. I will first look at the Dutch system from two perspectives: legal and sociological. I will then discuss the position of minorities in Dutch law, and finally make some concluding remarks.