Coupling mini-publics to collaborative governance: the case of the Education Reform in the Belgian French Speaking Community

Mini-publics are small face-to-face deliberative forums gathering lay citizens to provide decision makers with recommendations on a particular topic. They are increasingly used as a way to cure the malaise of representative democracy (Newton & Geissel, 2012). In order to maximize their potential, scholars have explored the ways to incorporate these deliberative forums into the policy-making process (Gastil, Ryan, & Smith, 2017). Hitherto, they have however neglected the shift from government to governance (Papadopoulos, 2012a). This new paradigm puts forward a more horizontal and coope... Mehr ...

Verfasser: Vrydagh, Julien
Devillers, Sophie
Reuchamps, Min
Democratic Innovations in Theory & Practice
Dokumenttyp: conferenceObject
Erscheinungsdatum: 2018
Schlagwörter: Deliberative democracy / Collaborative governance
Sprache: Englisch
Permalink: https://search.fid-benelux.de/Record/base-27305413
Datenquelle: BASE; Originalkatalog
Powered By: BASE
Link(s) : http://hdl.handle.net/2078.1/218444

Mini-publics are small face-to-face deliberative forums gathering lay citizens to provide decision makers with recommendations on a particular topic. They are increasingly used as a way to cure the malaise of representative democracy (Newton & Geissel, 2012). In order to maximize their potential, scholars have explored the ways to incorporate these deliberative forums into the policy-making process (Gastil, Ryan, & Smith, 2017). Hitherto, they have however neglected the shift from government to governance (Papadopoulos, 2012a). This new paradigm puts forward a more horizontal and cooperative form of the policy-making process in which various stakeholders are involved through a variety of cooperative schemes. Therein, mini-publics become one additional site of deliberation among others, implying that it interacts with and reports to a variety of new institutional actors. Very few studies have tried to understand how the stakeholders and the participants of these mini-publics perceive the mini-public newcomer in the cooperative schemes and how they deem its contribution to the policy-making process. This research questions how participants and stakeholders perceive the empowerment of deliberative forums in a policy-making process. Do stakeholders regard mini-publics as detrimental to their influence? Are participants willing to take over some power of the stakeholders? In order to answer these questions, we focus on a major Education Reform in the Belgian French-speaking Community, “Le Pacte pour un Enseignement d’Excellence†(2015–2018). This case features three mini-publics and the characteristics of collaborative governance, that is a substantial collaboration between the State and organized stakeholders in a policy-making process. We collected original data through surveys of stakeholders and mini-publics’ participants. This research aims to shed new light on how these two groups perceive each other so as to better understand how they can achieve a better coupling. In this case, we will se ...