Measuring and Comparing Planning Cultures: Risk, Trust and Co-operative Attitudes in Experimental Games

peer reviewed ; Cultural impacts in planning increasingly receive attention from both academics and practitioners around Europe. However, comparative planning cultures studies face the challenges of lacking systematic comparison and empirical evidence, especially at the micro level of planning actors’ behaviour in interaction. This article aims to fill these gaps by (1) operationalizing the concept of planning culture; and (2) measuring and comparing it. We base our operationalization on the culturized planning model (Knieling & Othengrafen, 2009). We complement its explanatory power by bu... Mehr ...

Verfasser: Li, Keyang
Dethier, Perrine
Eika, Anders
Samsura, Ary A.
van der Krabben, Erwin
Nordahl, Berit
Halleux, Jean-Marie
Dokumenttyp: journal article
Erscheinungsdatum: 2020
Verlag/Hrsg.: Carfax Publishing
Schlagwörter: comparative planning cultures / attitudes / experiment / Belgium / The Netherlands / Norway / Social & behavioral sciences / psychology / Regional & inter-regional studies / Sciences sociales & comportementales / psychologie / Etudes régionales & interrégionales
Sprache: Englisch
Permalink: https://search.fid-benelux.de/Record/base-27201288
Datenquelle: BASE; Originalkatalog
Powered By: BASE
Link(s) : https://orbi.uliege.be/handle/2268/234987

peer reviewed ; Cultural impacts in planning increasingly receive attention from both academics and practitioners around Europe. However, comparative planning cultures studies face the challenges of lacking systematic comparison and empirical evidence, especially at the micro level of planning actors’ behaviour in interaction. This article aims to fill these gaps by (1) operationalizing the concept of planning culture; and (2) measuring and comparing it. We base our operationalization on the culturized planning model (Knieling & Othengrafen, 2009). We complement its explanatory power by building a link between planning culture and planning outcome through attitudes of planning actors. This article focuses on three attitudes: risk, trust and co-operation. To measure and compare these attitudes, we adopt three experimental economic games and conduct an experiment with public and private planning practitioners in three European countries: Belgium, the Netherlands and Norway. Both crosscountry and public-private differences in these attitudes are tested in the experiment. Our experimental findings suggest that Dutch planning actors value risk aversion and trust; Norwegian planning actors value co-operation; while (French-speaking) Belgian planning actors do not value these variables that much. This empirical evidence is largely in line with more general evidence of differences in societal cultures in these countries ; JPI Urban Europe - SimsCity ValueCap