Sale held at Clinton Hall Art Galleries. ; "Among the paintings are choice examples by the following renowned artists: Kaulbach, Gallait, Merle, Alfred Stevens, Bouguereau, Van Marcke, Chaplin, Rousseau, Maréchal, Ed. Frère, Willems, Baron Leys, Koller, Koekkoek, Troyon, Tassaert, Lafon, Richter, Billet, Breton, Diaz, Ziem, Desgoffe, Voltz, Achenbach, Gude, Cabanel, Jacque, Boutibonne, Fromentin, Baugniet, Hoff, &c., &c., &c." ; 154 lots. ; Lugt, F. Répertoire des catalogues de ventes publiques, ; Lancour, H. American art auction catalogues, 1785-1942, ; Knoedler Library. Complete title index of 26,000 volumes of sales, exhibitions, and salons in the Knoedler Library on microfiche, ; Date of sale: January 24, 1871 and January 25, 1871. ; Place of sale: New York. ; Mode of access: Internet. ; Binding, copy 1: maroon cloth; gilt binder's title: New York 1871. Library's copy 1 is the second of six items bound in: 1871 Feb.20 NeSo. ; Library's copy 1 annotated in pencil with most prices and a few other notes; has former library label of M. Knoedler & Co. on title page verso; stamped "16" on title page.